Happiness. It's relative.

Once in a writing group, the woman who sat across from me circled all the times the word “I” appeared in my essay. It was some godawful number. Though legitimate criticism, that she did all the circling and with such obvious glee made me dislike her for the duration.
So, of course, starting this blog post, there was an overwhelming and reflexive move to start with the word that was circled. But that impulse was resisted mightily.
Not everything is about you, Jan.
Our friend’s son delivered the eulogy today at her memorial service. He had a mane of wild black hair, a thin face, and very expressive eyebrows, handsome like his father, as handsome as his mother always said he was, but this was our first meeting.
The eulogy was beautifully written, poignant and funny. He spoke about waiting not so patiently in the grocery line while his mother inquired earnestly and at length about the health and wellbeing of the cashier. His mom’s intense caring about other people, her willingness to counsel his many friends when they were teens, her gentleness with new friends, all of it was so wonderful. Glowing.
Like the obits this morning.
How does it happen that everyone who dies is so great? Have all the mediocre people been spared?
Every dead person in the obits was a great cook and a fabulous hostess, went to all their grandchildren’s sporting events, and had an extraordinary garden (it’s this last one that really stings).
Let me tell you right now. It’s not easy writing a blog post without using the circled word. It’s very wearing.
Tomorrow, there will be an end to this forced denial of oneself in one’s writing for there isn’t another memorial service and the obits are only published on Wednesday and Sunday.
______________
Photo by Daniel Herron on Unsplash
Oh my… That woman was in a workshop with moi years ago and did the same circling critique on my paper. Re: obits. What happened to all the wonderful women who loved their grandchildren, made afghans, and won prizes for their pies at the county fair? THANKS, JAN!
I suppose this illustrates why I do not consider myself an official “writer” because I had no idea that “I” had become a bad word.
Just for the record, I really don’t have a problem with seeing the circled word used in essays! And when it comes to obituaries, maybe nobody is mediocre in the eyes of those who love them – either that, or maybe we chose only to remember the good bits 🙂
Thank you. One had a good chuckle.
I don’t know , we all have our own style and way of telling a story
The only criticism that stuck with me was not using multiple exclamation point. One is enough. But I have a LOT of trouble anyway. If it’s worth exclaiming over once, more should be better.
It’s like people thinking because King said once that you should avoid adverbs they have decided that they should NEVER use them. Hell, King uses adverbs all over the place. You can’t remove parts of speech and expect language to flow.